Central California Criminal Justice Committee


June 8, 2018

To our supporters and friends:

Fresno has a police auditor, officially called the Office of Independent Review. At CCCJC, our question is: “Who Audits the Auditor?” Our answer to the question is that nobody will audit the auditor unless we step in to do so. That is a role we have been striving to fill ever since the first auditor was hired in 2009.

That first auditor was Eddie Aubrey, who held the position from 2009-2011. CCCJC met regularly with Aubrey and constantly urged him to stand up to the Fresno Police Department (FPD) and see what could be done to improve it. His tenure was short, but he did make some significant recommendations.

Aubrey was followed in 2012 by Rick Rasmussen who held the position for the next five years. We met with Rasmussen on a regular basis as well, and he came to regard us as an unofficial community oversight board. We asked him a lot of tough questions. He never flinched and always gave us straight answers. He was critical of many FPD practices and made quite a few recommendations that ended up being adopted. He focused a lot on officer involved shootings (OIS). During his tenure there was a significant reduction in the number of OIS and also the number of shots fired during OIS was dramatically reduced. That came about in part because of changes in police training that Rasmussen had recommended. We supported Rasmussen in those efforts, while continuing to push him to look into other areas of potential police misconduct. We were trying to be the conscience of the community, continually nagging at him. We saw that as our role.

The current police auditor, John Gliatta, started in 2017. The CCCJC is meeting with Gliatta on a quarterly basis. Sometimes we make him uncomfortable, but we see that as our role. Someone has to hold the auditor’s feet to the fire, and we are the ones with the experience to do that.

So who audits the auditor? We do. And with your support we will continue in that role as time goes by and as serious policing issues come up, as indeed they are want to do. We are a low budget operation, but we do have some expenses. We do try to participate in the annual conferences of the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement (NACOLE). There we learn what other communities are doing to keep tabs on their police departments and get new ideas for how to improve oversight in Fresno. The national conference, which includes travel to distant locations, nearly breaks our small budget, but we see it as essential to our work.

Please help if you can. You can be assured that any donations will be put to good use.


Thank you

June 28, 2018 Chief’s Advisory Board Notes


Notes by Rebeca Rangle

June 28, 2018
5:30 pm
Roz Clarke
Leroy Candler
Pastor Eli Loera
Holly Marshall
Gary Moore (FUSD)
Jim Poptanich (rep)
Martin Rodriguez (Centro
Leon Velasco
Carol Mills
Nicole Linder


Opening Remarks by the Chief
– Incident occurred last Friday at the Woodward Park Neighborhood (David Hall’s 1 year old son was being watched by a nanny); forced entry and raped and kidnapped the nanny and took her to an ATM to withdraw money; breakthrough yesterday
– Shooting incidents at Ashlan and West Ave. at 11:30 pm. White SUV forced another vehicle of the road with the intent to rob an individual who had just stopped at an ATM
– Another shooting incident at Gettysburg from one car into another
– 17 year old senior from Memorial shot in the back of the head for attempted robbery (a vigil being held tonight)
Public Safety/Parks Tax Proposal(s)
– Here yesterday and gone today (last night)
– ¼ cent public safety tax
– ¼ cent parks tax
– 8000 signatures short on the parks initiative
– Luis and Paul were in support
– City Council voted not to leave it to the voters
– No new officers (down about 8% or 180 civilian positions over the last decade, despite 180,000 (22%) more calls for service)
– 72% of 911 calls are answered within 15 minutes; state standard is 90%; some 911 calls are not being answered for 8 minutes
– 150 calls waiting to be answered every day
– How many of you have had your home or car broken into or property stolen?
– Shotspotter is in 12% of the area; 14 square miles of the city of Fresno
– As of today, 815 officers (+ academy) are employed by Fresno PD (290 on patrol; 33 in the Field Training Program; 11 are in orientation; 73 are on long-term absence; 75 funded with an external funding and assigned to schools, buses (18), sanitation (3), union (2)—3 shifts each day; today, 40 officers on patrol; handle 1200 calls for service per day—the number of calls of a city of 1 million population; have the # of officers of a city of 250,000; FPD has 1.5 per officers per 1000 population (2.2 or 2.3 LA)
Medical Marijuana Dispensaries
– City Council looking at proposals for the number and location of dispensaries
– Chief favors 1 dispensary per council district
– 10% local tax being proposed
– Chief would need $2.7 mil for 16-20 dedicated officers for the narcotics unit to regulate and monitory the “black market” and street sales, etc.
– $1200 fine for illegal fireworks
Chief signs about 60 Commendation letters per week (timeliness is an issue)
Matt asked two questions:
1. What is the procedure for policy review and change within FPD? (Specifically referenced Recommendation #1 in last OIR Report regarding Policy 323):
ANSWER FROM CHIEF DYER: Policy can get changed 2-3 times per week; LexiPol is standardized policy consistent with state and case and federal law re: policing policies. Any policy change gets sent out by SGT Steve to all bargaining units, staff, legal team for input. FPOA can request for a “meet and confer.”
2. What is being done to address the findings from the FPOA sworn and non-sworn employees that found that 68% and 91% of officers and civilian employees cited low employee morale as a problem and the fact that 74% of civilian employees feel they are fairly compensation?
ANSWER FROM DYER: We are conducting another survey to focus on employee morale. The question that was asked on the survey was a PERCEPTION question about the general environment, not about one’s own morale.

Chief is very pleased with the Citizen Survey Results (they’ve had these results for a month, but they have not yet been released to the public):
– 75% feel safe in their residence
– 75% feel safe in neighborhood
– 64% feel safe walking in parks
– 77% feel safe shopping in Fresno
– 31% say violent crime is a problem in their neighborhood
– 35% say gangs are a serious threat in their neighborhood
– 50% say vandalism is a serious threat in their neighborhood
– 67% say traffic violations are a major problem
– 86.4% say FPD officers treat public with respect
– 91.2% say FPD officers are professional

Meeting adjourned at 7:20 pm

20 Maps That Explain Mass Incarceration in America

03/16/2016 Here is a real in depth look at the FACTS behind America’s Mass Incarceration Problem.



Death Penalty Focus

Dear Friend,

Hello, and welcome to this month’s issue of the Focus. The issue of mental illness and the death penalty was at the center of debates in several states in the past month, including Virginia, Alabama, and Texas. Ohio has a new lethal drug protocol and is getting ready to begin executions after along hiatus. Challenges to lethal drug protocols, questions about DNA evidence, and a growing opposition from conservative groups are hurdles other states are trying to overcome in their attempts to re-start the machinery of death. Marie Deans was often described as the “angel of death row” because of the hundreds of men she helped save from being executed, and now a Virginia law professor has written her biography. Much has been written or published about the death penalty in the past few weeks, and we have a list of books, magazines, and editorials we think you’ll be interested in reading.

William Morva Executed in Virginia in Spite of Pleas for Clemency
Representatives from the UN, a group of Virginia state lawmakers, newspaper editorials, and tens of thousands of people from around the country asked Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe to commute the sentence of William Morva, a mentally ill man, to life without parole, but he turned a deaf ear and allowed the execution to go forward last week.

U.S. Appeals Court Rules for Mentally Ill Texas Death Row Inmate
Stating that, “There is no justification for executing the insane, and no reasoned support for it,” a federal appeals court sent the case of Scott Panetti, a diagnosed paranoid schizophrenic, who was sentenced to death in 1995, back to a lower court with an order to authorize federal funds for a mental health expert and investigator to assist in his defense.

U.S. Supreme Court Rules for Alabama Death Row Inmate on Mental Health Defense
In a 5-4 ruling last month, the justices ruled that James McWilliams was entitled to an independent mental health expert to assist the defense in his 1986 trial.

Ohio Gears Up for Executions After Long Hiatus
A federal appeals court approved the state’s new lethal injection protocol, and officials quickly responded by scheduling 27 executions to take place over the next five years.

In Brief
From Florida, which has scheduled an execution for next month, its first since January 2016, to Nebraska, where lawyers for a man facing a death penalty trial have filed a lawsuit claiming its death penalty is unconstitutional, to Indiana, where officials have appealed a ruling suspending the state’s death penalty to the Indiana Supreme Court, states around the country continue to tinker with the broken death penalty system.

Voices: Todd Peppers
In a new biography, “A Courageous Fool,” Todd Peppers examines the life of Marie Deans, a woman who saved hundreds of men from Virginia’s death chamber, devoting her life to a cause that took a “tremendous physical and mental toll.”

While We’re on the Subject . . .
From the history of the “Innocence Movement” to the spiritual argument for abolition, there was no shortage of provocative analyses of the death penalty and its ramifications published in the past month. We have some suggested reading.

Connect with Us


Death Penalty Focus
5 Third Street, Suite 725
San Francisco, CA 94103
Tel: 415-243-0143

Chief’s Advisory Board Meeting August 2017

The Chief’s Monthly Advisory Board Meeting (CAB) was held at Fresno City Hall on August 31st.

Notes regarding the meeting were made by CCCJC member Rebeca Rangel and are posted here for review.


Any comments or suggestions are eagerly sought by the CCCJC.


learn_more_356x200Incarcerating Us is a feature-length documentary that exposes America’s prison problem and explores ways to unshackle the Land of the Free through vital criminal justice reforms. With 2.3 million people behind bars, the U.S. has the largest prison population in the history of the world.


News From the Gas Chamber


Working for alternatives to the death penalty
Dear Friend,

As I sat in the gas chamber, the door clanged shut.  I was alone and suddenly dizzy and disoriented. Fear welled up inside of me. In the profound silence I could hear my heart beat, and realized that people had sat here before me until their heart was stopped–at the hands of the government.

Those moments had a profound effect on me.

As a law enforcement professional who had worked on many death penalty cases, I had accepted an invitation to enter the pod that was the gas chamber of Parchman State Prison. This was a working gas chamber where the state of Mississippi killed its condemned prisoners. It never occurred to me that it would ultimately lead to me completely changing my views on capital punishment.

More than forty years ago, I lost a cousin to murder and, at the time,  I would not have objected to a death penalty had the killer ever been caught. I have worked in law enforcement and the criminal justice system for nearly fifty years, including 24 years in the FBI, often visiting prisons and death rows without really questioning the use of the death penalty. I was myself once partly responsible for an execution, having arrested a murderer who ultimately received the death penalty.

But after my experience in the gas chamber, my conviction was shaken. I started to think and reflect.  Following my retirement from the FBI,  I became involved in the international human rights movement and gradually my attitudes changed. I found I could no longer support the concept of capital punishment.

I am not someone who is soft on crime, quite the contrary, but I have come to realize that killing the killer does not help the victims and is not a deterrent to crime. The cost of state killings is also a major drain on state budgets–money that could be used to put more police officers on the streets. That is why I would now advocate for the life of my cousin’s killer.

This is why I support Death Penalty Focus (DPF) in their work to end the death penalty. They have been educating and mobilizing the public on this issue for more than 25 years. During that time, they have amplified the voices of law enforcement, murder victims’ family members, and exonerees.

Public opposition to the death penalty continues to grow and it is imperative that we do not let up now. That’s why I dedicate so much of my time and money to help DPF to put an end to this cruel and pointless practice once and for all. I hope you will join me by making a contribution generous within your means to help DPF in its work to replace the death penalty with justice that works for everyone.


Tom Parker
Federal Bureau of Investigation (ret.)
DPF Board Member

PS.  If you agree that we should end the death penalty, then please make tax-deductible donation today. If you have already made a contribution, thank you for your support.

Fresno PD Low Moral Problem

In a recent article in the Fresno BEE Newspaper, the editor referred to a moral problem within the Fresno Police Department.


Read the full article here.

Latest NACOLE Digest

Please read the latest NACOLE Digest here logo[1]

California’s New OpenJustice Website


Screenshot of the 2013 murder of an unarmed man at a traffic stop by police in Gardena, California via LA Times

On September 2nd this year, the California Department of Justice launched a new website that publishes data about police interactions with the public, including the number of people who die at the hands of police.

Called Open Justice, the initiative is being billed as the first of its kind to provide detailed data to the public on a variety of crime statistics, including the number of officers killed and assaulted while on duty. The California DOJ says that the effort is a step towards more transparency amidst America’s ongoing debate about citizens dying both in police custody and by cops on the street.

Read the rest of the article here.

reprint of article published 09/02/2015 in Gizmodo by Matt Novac. Read the full article here GIZMODO